Skip to content

Caste System Vs Class System Essays About Love

And yet, not really.
Yes, the system that forced so-called "untouchables" to clean public toilets was outlawed; yes, the importance of one's caste was eroding as India grew more middle class, especially in the big cities. But we all knew that caste clung to us all. It was everywhere.
In many cases, it was broadcast in our surnames. Political parties were created to cater to castes. Marriages and business alliances were plotted to further them. Castes stuck together.
And then there was the national quota system. Since India's lower castes had been systematically disadvantaged for so long, the state created a special quota of government jobs and university seats that would be reserved for the former lower castes. Think of it as affirmative action, mandated by the constitution.
By 1990, the quota rose to about 49%, and it applied to groups that were classified as "Other Backward Classes," "Scheduled Castes," and "Scheduled Tribes." The move to reserve seats for them at universities and government jobs was seen as a way to give these groups more opportunities at social mobility.
By and large, the Indian system of quotas has endured and been appreciated. In middle school civics, this type of affirmative action was explained as a bedrock of India's democracy, a way of reversing unjust systems of the past.
But there are small pockets of groups who resent the system.
A student with a backward caste certificate can get into a top university more easily than a peer without that certificate -- the grade required for admission is usually significantly lower. The rule often spurs frustration in India's intensely competitive schools.
The same goes for plum government jobs. "Why should a quota exist?" ask some of those who are fighting for only half of all available jobs.
What is often forgotten in those moments of frustration is that the people for whom these quotas exist represent some two thirds of India's population.
Their argument has often been that they need a larger quota, not a smaller one. They say they have few other routes to social mobility, especially given how disadvantaged they have been for decades on literacy, education, health care, and opportunities.
Outbreaks of violent protests have raked into an ugly spotlight the views of those people who are dissatisfied with affirmative action.
The most recent violence began with a group called the Jats, a fairly well-off community of farmers and traders in the northern Indian state of Haryana.
CNN spoke to some of the protesters, and they expressed frustration over the quota system: "Why is it harder for us to get into universities, to get jobs?" they asked.
And so they protested. But the protests turned deadly, with at least 16 killed in clashes with the police as the Jats set fire to buildings, damaged water canals, and blocked highways.
The Jats' protests mirror a similar set of protests last August by a group called the Patels, in Gujarat. The Patels were agitating for the removal of the quota system. Hundreds of thousands hit the streets to vent their anger in days of demonstrations that made international news.
The irony of the Patel and Jat clashes is that both groups are relatively wealthy, and the dominant castes in their respective states.
Haryana's Jats are known as land owners with political clout. Gujarat's Patels are also farmers and landowners, and are seen as being enterprising and entrepreneurial -- many have started successful businesses. Others still have migrated to South Africa, Britain, and the United States. Patels own and run hundreds of small motels across the United States -- they're jokingly referred to as "potels."
Despite their relative wealth, the grievances of communities like the Patels and Jats are not imagined. Many struggle for jobs and advancement. Many worry about the dwindling influence of land owners.
Vipul Mudgal points out in an essay in The Wire that India's land owners are far less influential than they used to be. Mudgal cites government data to show that the average land holding in 1960 used to be 2.63 acres; by 2003 it had dropped to 1.06 acres.
That fall has likely worsened since. In short, India has gotten more populous, more urban, less dependent on agriculture and more dependent on services -- and its formerly wealthy land owners are facing a rapid loss in status.
Writing about the Patel movement in August, the social scientist Christopher Jaffrelot described in The Indian Express how a fast-changing India has been difficult for rural Indians.
"There is always some substance in mass movements," he wrote. "Patels may well be victims of the neo-middle class syndrome. Those who have not yet arrived, who are part of this aspiring class, and find it difficult to achieve their goals because jobs are scarce, education is expensive, buying a car is hard."
The Jats say they are working on a deal with the government. But there is no doubt they will not be the last example of caste politics in a fast-changing India.
Delivering water to Delhi's thirsty residents02:19
Deadly protests deplete water supply in New Delhi02:21

"The God Of Small Things": Reflection, Caste System, Boundaries And Barriers, Hierachy, Partiarchal Society Letter Format

Dear Velutha,I recently read The God of Small Things, by Arundhati Roy and was awfully touched by your story. Before I started reading The God of Small Things I knew very little about Indian society and history and consequently I found many of the themes and ideas of the novel intriguing as well as confronting. I was amazed to discover what a significant role the Caste System plays in Indian society and I was astounded by the negative impact is has on many, if not all of the novel's characters' lives and the boundaries and barriers it creates that prevent characters form being able to find fulfilment. I found reading about the love laws like reading a horror story and I was astounded by the fact that somebody like you could be bashed to death for simply falling in love. The novel also made me question the importance of 'small things' and the effect they have my own happiness. You are a very likeable character and one that I, as a western observer who knows no barriers as brutal as the Indian love laws, can sympathise with on many levels.

Throughout the novel Roy uses foreshadowing to suggest the idea that the characters futures have already been written. From the early stages of the novel we are aware that your affair with Ammu will bring an end to both of your lives. Yet the heart wrenching moments you shared were made all the worse by the implicit understanding that your love will eventually destroy you both. "The twins were too young to know that these were only history's henchmen. Sent to square the books and collect the dues from those who broke its laws." Roy describes how in the face of this social hierarchy your ending was inevitable; the police did what they had to do in order to keep the cast system afloat and secure its future, "The posse of Touchable Policemen acted with economy, not frenzy. Efficiency not anarchy. Responsibility, not hysteria."I found the description of your death and the approach the police implement awful, yet intriguing. The idea of murder simply being 'duty' in order to keep social order is one I have not considered and I found the lack of emotion shown by the officers disturbing. This novel made me question whether man has a natural tendency to create hierarchical structures. I believe it is part of mans nature to crave power and structure to re-enforce it. It has become clear to me since reading the novel that there will always be classes within societies and people who have higher status than others. I think that everybody deserves equal rights and opportunities and I think it is awful that people at the lower end of society generally have a lower chance of...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

The God of Small Things: Lessons of History

1921 words - 8 pages Time and space have always posed a threat to all creative artists. To move with time is the easiest way. To move back and forth is also not impossible. But to be timeless and space less- this is the real challenge. Yet any artist worthy of his vocation has in one way or another tried to resolve this riddle. How far he has succeeded is the real test of his genius. It does not simply mean neglecting the concept of linear time. Rather, it is...

The God of Small Things by Arundhati Roy

2647 words - 11 pages The God of Small Things by Arundhati Roy In The God of Small Things the twin’s mother, Ammu, breaks the laws that lay down ‘who should be loved, and how and how much’ when she has an affair with Velutha (an Untouchable). A relationship with an Untouchable is inconceivable in India, even today, as a woman would be expelled from her Caste if she were to carry out such an undignified act. Before this occurs Ammu is already frowned upon for...

The God of Small Things: A Plot Summary

1770 words - 7 pages Although desire presents itself in many charged forms in The God of Small Things, we can view the plot of the narrative as a series of disrupted yet connected events that are propelled by, or a product of, individual resistance fuelled by a Desire to Transgress. This plot of individual resistance is represented through the female protagonist Ammu and her daughter Rahel, as a foil of her mother, and is most explicit in the ending of the novel,...

Corporeality Gender and Race Positioning: The God of Small Things by Arundhati Roy

2823 words - 11 pages In The God of Small Things, Roy ingeniously exposes and denounces the politics of the subaltern through questions of corporeality gender and race positioning. She does so, however, in a way that escapes facile dichotomous divisions and obvious essentialist oppositions. At the core of her critique is a social and cultural system that not only stifles individual freedom and social mobility but also, and above all, represses the expressions of the...

Taboos and Love Laws in "The God of Small Things" by Arundhati Roy .

2193 words - 9 pages Taboos exist in all societies; they are the conventions that govern behaviour and conduct. The basic definition of taboo is: "Any conventional social restriction" (Webster's New World Dictionary 600). This characterizes what is meant by a taboo very clearly, but, taboos are not always universal; they change with time and place. Furthermore, taboos may exist in all societies but are not recognized nor are violators prosecuted the same in all....

Imagined Communities in the God of Small Things, No Telephone to Heaven, and Burger's Daughter

1162 words - 5 pages In Imagined Communities, Benedict Anderson sets forth his theory of the nation, that "it is an imagined political community - and imagined as both inherently limited and sovereign." The kinds of communities envisioned by the three main novels we have studied thus far are not all that dissimilar. These communities are stifling for the main characters, who all seek some form or another of acceptance: Clare, to feel at home within on culture or...

The Oppression of Colonized India Illustrated in Arundhati Roy’s Novel The God of Small Things

1527 words - 6 pages The post colonial experience has made the goal of harmonious family relationships that much more difficult, due to the families fragmenting throughout the old country and immigration to the land of the colonizer. Children and adult children alike lose perspective on their homeland and the struggles within their homeland. They become awe-struck by the development of the colonizers land, and as a result become confused with where their loyalties...

The Kite Runner and the Caste System

1985 words - 8 pages I chose to do my paper on the caste system. The caste system is an inherited social ranking of the classes and plays an important role throughout the Kite Runner. The book sates that there needs to be an order of the people to make sense of things worthwhile. The two boys try to defy that the caste system is nothing more than a state of mind. The Afghan people feel alienated from their own history because of the caste system. Kite fighting...

The Caste System: History and Highlights

1690 words - 7 pages In every civilization there exists a hierarchy that is accepted by the people that are a part of it. This hierarchy, which is present in all societies, is called a class system and usually includes an upper class, a middle class, and a lower class. The upper class consists of those who are the richest in a society, the middle class consists of the working people, and the lower class consists of the poorest people. There is one class system that...

The Effects of the Indian Caste System

1120 words - 4 pages Dating all the way back to 1200 BCE, social classes have helped define India’s politics, religion, and its society. The name of the system that the Indians used to classify social classes was the caste system, a way to classify people into ranks, called varnas. There are four ranks that were created in order to classify the people: at the top were the Brahmans, then the Kshatriyas, the Vaishyas, and finally the Shudras. The Rig Vedas states that,...

Caste System, The Scourge of Indian Civilization

2818 words - 11 pages Caste system has been the scourge of Indian civilization and culture. The battle against this oppressive and inhuman is older than even some of the great religions of the world. The first warrior to wage against this system was probably Gautam Buddha who waged the war against this inhuman system in 6th century B.C. No doubt, Buddha was able to put some dents in the system, but after the Nirvana of Buddha, the system once again rose like a phoenix...